Millennials worse off. But Why?

Arguably, one of the most disturbing aspects that have emerged from the now seemingly unresolvable housing crisis, is the manner in which we have succumbed to the notion that younger Australians will necessarily be worse off than their parents.

By any measure, thirty consecutive years of economic growth should be an adequate foundation from which the largest generational cohort can now forge significant social, cultural, and economic momentum. As a nation with such vast physical, economic, and human resources, there is every reason why the 2020s should be a golden period for Australia’s Millennials. Instead, the continued trajectory of the housing crisis will entrench many of them – despite their ambitions – as long-term renters, generating both individual and broader societal costs.

Notwithstanding the best-intended interventions, any attempt to resolve this issue needs to begin with recognising in what, why and how, Millennials want to live. Unsurprisingly, just like their generational peers of the past, the vast majority of 35–44-year-olds reside in Houses. That they choose to settle down and form families at a rate greater than any other age group is a basic, but obvious reason for this.

In recent years, alternate dwelling types have become more popular for the 35-44 cohort, albeit to varying degrees in different markets. Townhouses have become increasingly attractive, particularly in Melbourne, where it is the preferred dwelling type for just over 16% of 35–44-year households, up from 11.3% in 2011. Brisbane also experienced a similar increase, now at 10.5%, up from 6.8% in 2011. Notably, Sydney experienced a 0.4% decrease in Townhouse occupancy by 35–44-year-olds over this time.

Reflective of a widespread trend across most age cohorts, fewer 35–44-year-old households, now occupy Apartments (up to three storeys) than they did in 2011. Melbourne has experienced the greatest decline, falling from 10.3% to 7.9% in 2021, followed by Sydney which fell from 15.4% to 14%.

In Melbourne, just under 8% of 35–44-year-olds occupy Apartments (four storeys or more) – up from 2.8% in 2011. In Sydney this figure is a sizeable 20%, an increase from 10.4% in 2011, while in Brisbane it remains a lowly 3.5%, up from 2.2% in 2011. Yet to establish itself as a long-term living option for a large portion of the population, the delivery of this format in the numbers required to make any meaningful impact on the widening supply gap is heavily constrained. It will remain so for the foreseeable future.

For decades, home ownership has been fundamental to the nation’s social contract, its well-being, and its prosperity. Simply accepting that younger Australians will be worse off than their parents might be the easy thing to do, but it’s certainly not the wisest.

 

Millennials by dwelling type

Remote working for Sydney CBD workers on the rise

Following our analysis of Melbourne CBD workers last week, the chart below highlights the change in the number of Sydney CBD workers reporting their place of usual residence being outside of the Greater Sydney area. The number of Sydney CBD workers reporting their place of usual residence as outside of Greater Sydney increased by a greater magnitude than seen in Melbourne over 2016 to 2021, rising by 110% from 8,250 in 2016 to 17,250 in 2021. Much of the increase will have been a response to the lockdowns through the COVID pandemic creating a desire for more space, and aided by the ability for many to be able to work remotely. The figure represents 5.1% of the total number of Sydney CBD workers.

As would be expected, the largest increases were experienced in the Hunter and Illawarra regions (as well as the Central Coast, which is within Greater Sydney). These locations are still close enough to commute from on an infrequent basis, while offering significant amenity, affordability benefits and lifestyle attributes.

There were also notable increases in more distant regions, such as the Northern Rivers coast and South Coast, as well as the major coastal centres of Port Macquarie and Coffs Harbour. Inland, Orange experienced a notable increase in Sydney CBD workers.

Notably, the aggregate increase in Sydney CBD workers in regional New South Wales (+3,000) was outnumbered by the rise in those living interstate, which increased from 2,834 in 2016 to 8,913 in 2021 (+6,079). Interestingly, despite the harsher lockdowns in Victoria through the COVID pandemic, Victoria surpassed Queensland over 2016-2021 as the state with the most Sydney CBD workers.

Regional centres will have benefited from the migration of these remote workers, who are likely to be on higher incomes than the existing population and supporting local businesses. On the flipside, downsides have also emerged in the form of reduced availability of rental stock, with significant increases in rents and values reducing affordability for locals. Further analysis of this demographic will assist in providing more insight into ways to manage the emerging stresses.