Millennials worse off. But Why?

Arguably, one of the most disturbing aspects that have emerged from the now seemingly unresolvable housing crisis, is the manner in which we have succumbed to the notion that younger Australians will necessarily be worse off than their parents.

By any measure, thirty consecutive years of economic growth should be an adequate foundation from which the largest generational cohort can now forge significant social, cultural, and economic momentum. As a nation with such vast physical, economic, and human resources, there is every reason why the 2020s should be a golden period for Australia’s Millennials. Instead, the continued trajectory of the housing crisis will entrench many of them – despite their ambitions – as long-term renters, generating both individual and broader societal costs.

Notwithstanding the best-intended interventions, any attempt to resolve this issue needs to begin with recognising in what, why and how, Millennials want to live. Unsurprisingly, just like their generational peers of the past, the vast majority of 35–44-year-olds reside in Houses. That they choose to settle down and form families at a rate greater than any other age group is a basic, but obvious reason for this.

In recent years, alternate dwelling types have become more popular for the 35-44 cohort, albeit to varying degrees in different markets. Townhouses have become increasingly attractive, particularly in Melbourne, where it is the preferred dwelling type for just over 16% of 35–44-year households, up from 11.3% in 2011. Brisbane also experienced a similar increase, now at 10.5%, up from 6.8% in 2011. Notably, Sydney experienced a 0.4% decrease in Townhouse occupancy by 35–44-year-olds over this time.

Reflective of a widespread trend across most age cohorts, fewer 35–44-year-old households, now occupy Apartments (up to three storeys) than they did in 2011. Melbourne has experienced the greatest decline, falling from 10.3% to 7.9% in 2021, followed by Sydney which fell from 15.4% to 14%.

In Melbourne, just under 8% of 35–44-year-olds occupy Apartments (four storeys or more) – up from 2.8% in 2011. In Sydney this figure is a sizeable 20%, an increase from 10.4% in 2011, while in Brisbane it remains a lowly 3.5%, up from 2.2% in 2011. Yet to establish itself as a long-term living option for a large portion of the population, the delivery of this format in the numbers required to make any meaningful impact on the widening supply gap is heavily constrained. It will remain so for the foreseeable future.

For decades, home ownership has been fundamental to the nation’s social contract, its well-being, and its prosperity. Simply accepting that younger Australians will be worse off than their parents might be the easy thing to do, but it’s certainly not the wisest.

 

Millennials by dwelling type

Net Overseas Migration Roaring Back

Interesting results from the September quarter 2022 population release published today by the Australian Bureau of Statistics.

  • Australia experienced a record quarterly net overseas migration (NOM) inflow of 106,200, only the second time quarterly NOM has exceeded 100,000 (after March quarter 2022). NOM for year to September 2022 was 303,700, just shy of the record 315,700 annual NOM in 2008.
  • Based on recent monthly arrivals and departures, as well as student visas granted, national NOM should easily surpass 350,000 in FY2023, and could even reach the 400,000 flagged by Westpac a couple of weeks ago. Victoria and New South Wales are attracting around two thirds of this total.
  • Interstate movements in September quarter 2022 were very low (73,600 persons), having been lower only twice in the past 20 years. This could be a hangover from the record interstate movement induced by the COVID pandemic and/or that lack of options for interstate migrants due to extremely low vacancy rates. Queensland, Western Australia and South Australia remain destination states, although Victoria’s recent high net interstate outflow fell to almost zero in the quarter and could move back into positive territory in December 2022 quarter.
  • Births registered in September quarter 2022 continued the lower level that emerged after the post-COVID bounce seen in calendar 2021. It will be interesting to see whether cost of living pressures will see births take another step down over the next year or two.
  • Deaths remain above the five year average, reflecting the trends already seen in the more current provisional data published by the ABS. In 2022, there were 174,717 deaths that occurred by 30 November and were registered by 31 January 2023. This was 22,886 deaths (15.1%) more than the baseline average. The higher deaths could play out for some time due to the limited preventative care that is likely to have taken place through COVID lockdowns.

Annual population growth (418,500) is now at its highest level since 2008-2009 and is on track to end at a new record in FY2023. The consequences of a turbo-charged population are evident in rental markets, which will tighten further in the absence of growth in new dwelling supply. Rising rents will contribute to inflationary pressures as will the increased demand for goods and services. Although adding to the overall labour pool, shortages for particular skills may be exacerbated if the lack of rental stock reduces worker mobility and restricts the ability for workers to move where there is demand.

Notably, the most recent ABS release highlights that the current publicly available population projections are now significantly undercooking population growth over the next couple of years. For further insight into what this means for population growth nationally and across the states, contact Angie Zigomanis at angie.zigomanis@quantifysi.com.au or Rob Burgess at rob.burgess@quantifysi.com.au